Overview A California administrative judge has denied Tesla's attempt to dismiss allegations made by the state’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) that the

California Judge Rejects Tesla's Bid to Dismiss Misleading Self-Driving Claims


blog post cover photo

Image credit: Bram Van Oost


A California administrative judge has denied Tesla's attempt to dismiss allegations made by the state's Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) that the automaker misled consumers about the capabilities of its self-driving technology.

Key Points:

  1. Judge's Decision:

    • Judge Juliet Cox from the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) ruled on Monday that the claims made by the California DMV, if proven true, justify enforcement action against Tesla.
  2. California DMV's Allegations:

    • In July 2022, the California DMV accused Tesla of overstating the capabilities of its Autopilot and Full Self-Driving (FSD) technologies in advertisements.
    • The DMV argued that Tesla's vehicles "could not at the time of those advertisements, and cannot now, operate as autonomous vehicles."
  3. Potential Consequences:

    • The DMV is seeking potential remedies that include suspending Tesla's license to sell vehicles in California and requiring the automaker to provide restitution to affected vehicle owners.
  4. Formal Review Date:

    • The accusations will undergo a formal review before the OAH on September 9.
  5. Previous Legal Challenges:

    • On May 15, a federal judge in San Francisco denied Tesla's motion to dismiss a proposed nationwide class-action lawsuit. This lawsuit claims Tesla misled consumers into believing their vehicles would soon achieve full self-driving capabilities.
  6. Federal Investigations:

    • Tesla has been under scrutiny for several years by federal authorities regarding whether its self-driving technology has contributed to fatal crashes.
  7. Tesla's Response:

    • As of now, Tesla and its legal representatives have not commented on the recent judicial decision. The DMV also declined to comment on the judge's decision.

Industry and Consumer Implications:

The ongoing legal and regulatory challenges Tesla faces concerning its Autopilot and FSD technologies highlight the importance of transparency and accuracy in advertising, especially in the rapidly evolving field of autonomous driving. These challenges also underscore the potential consequences of overstating technological capabilities to consumers and the regulatory scrutiny that can follow.


This ruling is a significant development in the regulatory scrutiny Tesla faces over its self-driving technology claims. The upcoming formal review by the OAH will be a critical juncture in determining whether Tesla will face further penalties or required changes in its marketing and operational practices. As Tesla continues to push the boundaries of autonomous driving, these legal battles will likely influence how it and other automakers communicate their technological advancements to the public.

Discover High-Quality Investment Opportunities

Utilize advanced tools like Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis to identify and invest in high-quality stocks that align with Morgan Stanley's recommended strategy. Make informed investment decisions with comprehensive financial insights. Learn More

Other Blogs

Nov 25, 2023 6:39 AM - Parth Sanghvi

DCF Valuation vs. Comparable Companies Analysis: Choosing the Right Valuation Method

Choosing the Right Valuation Method: DCF vs. Comparable Companies Analysis Introduction: Valuation methods play a pivotal role in determining the fair value of a company, aiding investors in making informed investment decisions. Two commonly used methods, DCF Valuation and Comparable Companies A...

blog post title

Dec 23, 2023 2:19 AM - Parth Sanghvi

Understanding the Limitations of DCF Analysis: A Guide to Overcoming Challenges

Introduction: Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis stands as a cornerstone in valuing investments, yet its efficacy is contingent upon various assumptions and methodologies. While a powerful tool, DCF analysis comes with inherent limitations and challenges that investors must acknowledge to make i...

blog post title

Dec 25, 2023 2:28 AM - Parth Sanghvi

Integrating Sustainability into Valuations: Navigating ESG Factors within the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Model

Introduction: The investment landscape is undergoing a profound shift with a heightened emphasis on sustainability and responsible investing. In this blog post, we explore the intersection of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations within the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model, h...

blog post title


Financial Modeling Prep API provides real time stock price, company financial statements, major index prices, stock historical data, forex real time rate and cryptocurrencies. Financial Modeling Prep stock price API is in real time, the company reports can be found in quarter or annual format, and goes back 30 years in history.
2017-2024 © Financial Modeling Prep